Customer Reviews

I have been with McCabe Insurance since the early 80s. They are a wonderful insurance company. They insure my house and my vehicle. Over the years it has been such a pleasure to work with them. They always answer all my questions. They have helped me so many times and are friends and professional. They truly care about their customers as you can see that through how they treat you when you call. Recently I was working with purchasing a new vehicle and Geoff Schwartz who went above and beyond to help me out when working with the dealership. I highly recommend McCabe Insurance Associates to everyone. You will not be disappointed.

I've been with McCabe for over 30 yrs. They have always been friendly and professional. If I have a question Geoff is quick to respond. He's helped me with other family members as I've encouraged them to work with Geoff. Great company and personnel. Highly recommend!!!!

Great

We have worked with Sharon Dages for years and she has been great.

Natalie’s customer service is great. Erie Insurance is competitively priced AND their service is also great. I’ve been very happy with McCabe for the 15-20 years I’ve been with you.

McCabe is wonderful. When I lost my car in a flood the insurance process was so easy to navigate. It was such a stressful time in my life, and McCabe made it 10x easier, and gave me an insurance payout that was exactly what I was hoping for. I will use McCabe as long as I am able!

There is someone there to answer my call and questions and always helpful service!

Sharon is so great I feel like I have known her forever. She goes above and beyond. I would recommend Mc Cabe to anyone.

i got a DUI, the court said I needed a special insurance rider. I called McCabe and they said they never heard of it. They would hand it to the underwriters. I called back 4 times in 5 weeks and did not hear a thing. Finally I got a cancellation notice in the mail. They gave me a date that my policy would die and tried to charge me for it. I called a local company and was insured before I could say thank you. I don;t know why in the hell they would want feed back from a guy they fucked. Crazy world.

I've been with McCabe for over 20+ years. Everyone has always been very responsive helpful when needed. Very satisfied with the service they provide.