Customer Reviews
Consistently provides fast, friendly and knowledgeable service....
Consistently provides fast, friendly and knowledgeable service.
—Anonymous
I received fast and efficient service from everyone at McCabe Insurance Agency....
I received fast and efficient service from everyone at McCabe Insurance Agency. They are professional and thorough in their care of my insurance needs. I would highly recommend them.
—Anonymous
We came to Geoff at McCabe after a not great experience with another agent....
We came to Geoff at McCabe after a not great experience with another agent. Switching to Jeff and McCabe has been night and day. Great quick service and extremely knowledgeable. They reevaluated our coverage and insured we were covered for everything we really should be in my premium even went down. Very responsive and we are happy we made the switch
—Anonymous
We had the pleasure of working with Mayela Cubillo to secure both car and home......
We had the pleasure of working with Mayela Cubillo to secure both car and home insurance, and we couldn’t be happier with her service! She was incredibly patient and thorough, taking the time to present multiple options to ensure we got the best coverage at the best rates. Her expertise made the whole process smooth and stress-free, and we felt confident in every decision thanks to her guidance. If you're looking for someone who genuinely cares and will go the extra mile for you, I highly recommend Mayela. She truly makes a difference!
—Jessica L
I have been using McCabe for over 30 years. Started with my Dad and I continue...
I have been using McCabe for over 30 years. Started with my Dad and I continue the tradition. So nice , personal and caring. Makes you feel like you are their only client.
—Anonymous
DM
Very responsive and forthcoming with information that has been relevant to our...
Very responsive and forthcoming with information that has been relevant to our needs. This included prior business related insurance and now personal insurance.
—David M
After being an Erie policy holder for more than 30 years, we have referred both...
After being an Erie policy holder for more than 30 years, we have referred both of our adult sons to Erie. Erie's coverage is superior and the cost of their policies have been less than quotes from other companies they received while shopping around for insurance. Sharon feels like she is a member of our family. She always takes care of our needs.
—Anonymous
A human always answers the phone (almost always) and is always able to either...
A human always answers the phone (almost always) and is always able to either handle my issue or direct me to someone who can. Service is friendly, welcoming, and complete. Keep it up.
—Anonymous
LC
Your agents are always friendly, knowledgeable and professional...
Your agents are always friendly, knowledgeable and professional
—Larry C
Great service from Mayela Cubillo every time!...
Great service from Mayela Cubillo every time!
—Justin C
