Read what some of our satisfied insurance customers have to say! If you’d like to provide your feedback, please submit your online review.
- 5 stars
- The work associates at McCabe Insurance are outstanding.
- Thank you Sharon for great customer service!
- They came to my rescue when a tree fell on my house.
“Thank you Robyn Toulotte and McCabe and Erie Insurance! They came to my rescue when a tree fell on my house. From my first call to Robyn minutes after the tree fell, to the temporary representative I had till we were assigned a permanent one, everyone was responsive, professional and extremely helpful. Lucky for me Robyn sold us replacement insurance with a manageable deductible. Once the adjuster walked our property, it took them about 2 weeks to send us a check with the understanding that if the contractor found something they did not see, they would adjust the payment accordingly. They also sent out an adjuster to inventory my personal items that were damaged. I received that check about 2 weeks after as well. I was able to hire the contractor I wanted and finally, we are moving back into our home next week. Thanks everyone for making this very difficult time in my families life a little easier. I will continue to recommend your services.”
- A great team to work with!
- I have been a member for years,...
“I have been a member for years, but most recently I have had an amazing experience with this company. I have a terribly unresponsive mortgage company who ironically was insisting on some insurance information from me. I reached out to Ms Odelys Payano and agent with MCcabe Insurance for help and i was so stressed about getting this information by the mortgage company’s. Ms. Payano was very persistent in making sure that my mortgage company had what they needed. I am so grateful for people like this and because of her, I give this you 5 stars. Thank you again.”
“I have been with McCabe since around 1999, after being referred to them by my father. I used them for car insurance first, then renter’s insurance and when I purchased my first home in 2004, I added homeowner’s insurance. I trust McCabe and now my partner also uses them for his business -both vehicle and workshop. He especially likes working with the commercial agent Natalie as she is always available to answer questions and responds quickly to any needs. ”
“While we have all had difficult times in these last two years, I faced significant personal challenges that were almost overwhelming. Almost. The help and compassion and support I received from Geoff made a great deal of difference. It is wonderful to know that I not only have an insurance provider but a supportive friend in him. I get requests all the time to switch plans. Saving pennies would never mean as much to me as the assurance I have that I will be taken care of personally. ”