Customer Reviews

We have been with McCabe Insurance for many years now. We always get prompt, friendly service when we contact them. As far as I'm concerned, they set the standard by which all other insurance companies are measured.

I am very satisfied about the prompt response.

I emailed a picture of the new registration and it was added quickly.

Responsiveness to questions. Honest answers without trying to upsell.

Very professional good jobs

When we had an accident (not our fault) our claim was taken care of fast.

Geoff Schwartz at McCabe Insurance was excellent to work with. I was shopping home, auto, and umbrella insurance during a tight home-closing timeline, and he was responsive, clear, and patient throughout the process. He walked me through the coverage options, answered detailed questions, corrected assumptions when needed, and helped optimize the bundle for both cost and protection. He also coordinated quickly with my lender on the evidence of insurance so the closing process could keep moving. Overall, Geoff made a stressful part of buying a home much easier. Highly recommend working with him.

When I called McCabe Insurance in a bit of a frenzy, Geoff Schwartz took extremely good care of me. He was kind and patient. He handled all of my insurance needs and worked out a policy that fit within my budget.

Our experience has been very positive.

Needed a quote for homeowners insurance for a new place. Received quickly. Another reason I stay with McCabe.